What was long anticipated as an epic confrontation between the federal government and the “tax honesty” movement has gone up in smoke, with the cancellation of the planned Feb. 27 and 28 tax policy forum in Washington by the congressman that had been the aggrieved petitioners’ greatest official supporter.
“I am quite dismayed by Operation “Wait to File until the Trial,” said Rep. Roscoe G. Bartlett, R-Md., in a press release. Bartlett communicated his decision in a letter to Robert L. Schulz, chairman of the board of We The People Foundation for Constitutional Education, Inc., who had requested the forum.
In his letter to Schulz, Bartlett wrote: “The information that you are currently disseminating concerning the February 27 & 28 forum is misleading. I will not be a party to advocating the non-payment of federal income taxes.”
We The People, an organization that disputes, on various grounds, the legality of the federal income tax, has been urging Americans to hold off filing their 2001 income tax returns until after the planned hearings in Washington, D.C., next month.
“The very legality of the U.S. income tax system goes on trial Feb. 27 at a congressionally sponsored public hearing on Capitol Hill,” said a statement on We The People’s website.
Bartlett, who was the congressional sponsor of the hearing, explained that Schulz’s “rhetoric has made it impossible for the forum to take place because the Internal Revenue Service and Department of Justice will not participate.”
The Maryland Republican “remains committed to ensuring the right of Bob Schulz and other citizens to exercise their constitutional rights under the First Amendment to get answers to their questions about federal tax policy from the government,” according to his press statement. As an alternative to the much-ballyhooed February confrontation, he offered to forward Schulz’s questions to both the Justice Department and Internal Revenue Service, and to post their answers on his congressional website.
Here is the text of Bartlett’s letter:
- Dear Bob:
I am quite dismayed by the tone of your rhetoric on your web page – “Wait to File Until the Trial.”
When I first met you in July of 2001, you seemed to want answers to questions regarding the legitimacy of the 16th Amendment to the Constitution. As a congressman who believes and follows the Constitution, you found a willing ear. In the numerous meetings that followed, I never advocated the non-payment of income taxes. You were quick to agree and assured me that you never took this position as well.
The information that you are currently disseminating concerning the February 27 & 28 forum is misleading. While I remain committed to making every effort so that you can exercise your constitutional right to get answers to your questions, your rhetoric has made it impossible for the forum to take place because the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) will not participate.
This is the alternative. I do not believe that IRS and DOJ will refuse to answer my questions. Please send the questions that you and your team developed to my Washington, D.C., office. I will refer them to the appropriate individuals at the IRS and the DOJ to respond. Since I know that there are thousands of people across this nation who want answers to similar questions, I will post both the questions and answers on my congressional web site.
In any future statements regarding my support, please be sure that it is clear that I am supporting your constitutional rights and not that I am advocating not filing and not paying taxes.
ROSCOE G. BARTLETT
Member of Congress
The tax group had expected, at the forum, “to prove conclusively that the IRS does not have the legal authority to force employers to withhold taxes from the paychecks of their employees, or to force most Americans to file a return or pay the income tax.”
“If the research is confirmed publicly, most Americans may be entitled to a refund of 100 percent of the income tax paid or withheld in 2001,” the statement continued.
“The IRS and Department of Justice will officially and publicly answer detailed legal allegations directly challenging the jurisdiction of the IRS and the unlawful enforcement and administration of U.S. income tax laws,” Schulz had said.
The two-day hearing had originally been scheduled for Sept. 24-25, but was postponed until next month in the wake of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.