A Ten Commandments monument inspired by ousted Alabama Supreme Court Justice Roy Moore was removed from a North Carolina city hall one day after it was installed by a council member.
Winston-Salem councilman Vernon Robinson |
Vernon Robinson, a candidate for a vacant U.S. House seat, said he paid $2,000 out of his personal funds to install the monument at the Winston-Salem city hall, which was deserted because of the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday, the Winston-Salem Journal reported.
The paper said a seven-man crew removed the one-ton granite block late this morning on the order of City Manager Bill Stuart. A backhoe carried the two-piece marker to a trailer attached to a city truck, which moved it to a warehouse where it will stay until Robinson comes to claim it.
Carrie Collins, the city's marketing and communications director, said city officials had not decided whether Robinson would pay for its removal.
Robinson's spokesman, Chris Younce, said the councilman was conferring with city officials and would be at the city council's meeting tonight, the Journal reported.
The monument's installation violated city policies requiring any display honoring public officials to be approved by the council and to have permission from the city manager to install it.
The councilman said he decided to install the monument after speaking in October with Moore, who was ousted as chief justice last November after refusing to remove a Ten Commandments monument from Alabama's state judicial building.
"This display is intended to acknowledge the undeniable role that the Ten Commandments and Bill of Rights have played in developing the American legal tradition," Robinson said, according to the Associated Press. "These are the ideas on which society has been built and these works encapsulate the belief system on which the republic was founded."
Robinson's five-foot tall monument has the Ten Commandments inscribed on one side facing Main Street and an abbreviated version of the Bill of Rights on the side facing city hall.
The city council member said he wanted the monument to be a surprise to the city's citizens and insisted he had no thought of what effect it would have on his campaign for the Republican nomination for the 5th Congressional District, the Winston-Salem paper said.
Ten Commandments monument paid for by city council member (Photo: Winston-Salem Journal) |
Robinson said he and four helpers set up the monument on the holiday because the adjoining parking lot was empty, allowing moving equipment to position the blue-granite block. But city officials criticized his actions, especially during a time when the community was celebrating Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
"Obviously if you are going to do something like this, this is not the right way to do it," Mayor Allen Joines said, according to the Journal. "We are working hard to bring the city together. Actions like this tend to push people apart."
City Council Member Dan Besse called it "another political stunt."
The Winston-Salem paper said Robinson's peers often have complained about grandstanding and campaigning from his council seat.
Robinson said he didn't seek permission to put up the monument because he didn't know the procedure, although he admitted he came up with the idea in October.
He said he believes the marker is constitutional because it is not publicly funded or overtly religious.
"This monument is not an effort to proselytize; it is a history lesson," he said, according to the Winston-Salem daily. "Atheists may complain about history, but the words are still history."
Robinson said he did not think it would have any effect on the campaign, but supporters of the public display of the Ten Commandments said they were not so sure.
"I don't know that this kind of grandstanding promotes the understanding of our heritage," said state Sen. Virginia Fox, according to the Journal, adding it would be more sincere if it was erected by someone not running for office.
The honorary chairman for Robinson's campaign is former senator and vice-presidential candidate Jack Kemp, who calls him a "true Ronald Reagan conservative."
Kemp said Robinson has "led the fight for school choice, less government spending, and pro-growth tax cuts in North Carolina for many years."
Related stories:
Official installs Commandments at city hall
Roy Moore asks high court to restore him
Roy Moore files notice to regain position
Roy Moore to appeal removal from office
Alabama voters file suit to restore Moore
Roy Moore owes Alabama $7,000?
Roy Moore plans bill to curb federal courts
Alabama moves to oust Judge Moore
Moore takes Decalogue battle to D.C.
Judge to hear lawsuit on 10 Commandments
Dobson, Keyes to join Moore rally
ACLU, Moore agree on 10 Commandments?
Judge Roy Moore: 'Captain America'
10 Commandments showdown tonight
Backers of 10 Commandments to rally